Officers
| Year Elected | President | Executive Director* |
| 2011 | Stanley Hauerwas | Stacey Floyd-Thomas |
| 2010 |
Douglas Ottati |
Stewart W. Herman |
| 2009 | Daniel Finn | Stewart W. Herman |
| 2008 | Darryl Trimiew | Stewart W. Herman |
| 2007 | Christine Gudorf | Stewart W. Herman |
| 2006 | William Werpehowski | Stewart W. Herman |
| 2005 | Jean Porter | Regina Wentzel Wolfe |
| 2004 | John Langan, S.J. | Regina Wentzel Wolfe |
| 2003 | June E. O'Connor | Regina Wentzel Wolfe |
| 2002 | William F. May | Regina Wentzel Wolfe |
| 2001 | Gene Outka | Regina Wentzel Wolfe |
| 2000 | Harlan R. Beckley | Dennis P. McCann |
| 1999 | Robin W. Lovin | Dennis P. McCann |
| 1998 | Ronald M. Green | Dennis P. McCann |
| 1997 | Lisa Sowle Cahill | Dennis P. McCann |
| 1996 | Charles H. Reynolds | Dennis P. McCann |
| 1995 | David Hollenbach | John H. Cartwright |
| 1994 | Jon P. Gunnemann | John H. Cartwright |
| 1993 | Margaret A. Farley | John H. Cartwright |
| 1992 | Joseph L. Allen | John H. Cartwright |
| 1991 | Peter Paris | John H. Cartwright |
| 1990 | Larry L. Rasmussen | Charles H. Reynolds |
| 1989 | Karen Lebacqz | Charles H. Reynolds |
| 1988 | Theodore R. Weber | Charles H. Reynolds |
| 1987 | John H. Yoder + | Charles H. Reynolds |
| 1986 | Max L. Stackhouse | Terence R. Anderson |
| 1985 | Major J. Jones + | Terence R. Anderson |
| 1984 | Alan Geyer | Terence R. Anderson |
| 1983 | Thomas W. Ogletree | Joseph L. Allen |
| 1982 | Beverly W. Harrison | Joseph L. Allen |
| 1981 | Daniel C. Maguire | Joseph L. Allen |
| 1980 | Douglas Sturm | Joseph L. Allen |
| 1979 | Donald Shriver, Jr. | Max L. Stackhouse |
| 1978 | Walter Muelder + | Max L. Stackhouse |
| 1977 | Waldo Beach + | Max L. Stackhouse |
| 1976 | J. Philip Wogaman | Max L. Stackhouse |
| 1975 | Preston N. Williams | Franklin Sherman |
| 1974 | Roger L. Shinn | Franklin Sherman |
| 1973 | Charles C. West | Franklin Sherman |
| 1972 | Edward L. Long, Jr. | Franklin Sherman |
| 1971 | Charles E. Curran | Douglas Sturm |
| 1970 | John Satterwhite+ | Douglas Sturm |
| 1969 | James F. Gustafson | Douglas Sturm |
| 1968 | James Luther Adams+ | Douglas Sturm |
| 1967 | Murray H. Leiffer+ | E. Clinton Gardner |
| 1966 | Victor Obenhaus | E. Clinton Gardner |
| 1965 | Paul Elmen+ | E. Clinton Gardner |
| 1964 | Prentiss Pemberton + | E. Clinton Gardner |
| 1963 | Walter Sikes + | Das Kelley Barnett |
| 1962 | Paul Ramsey + | Das Kelley Barnett |
| 1961 | E. Clinton Gardner + | Das Kelley Barnett |
| 1960 | John C. Bennett + | Das Kelley Barnett |
| 1959 | Henry E. Kolbe + | Das Kelley Barnett |
+ Deceased
*In 1994 the title of the Executive Secretary was changed to Executive Director.
